If nothing else, Spike Priggen is a generous man. Not only does he offer both Stars After Stars After Stars and his first album, The Very Thing That You Treasure, for free download on his website; he also sent us a CD featuring the originals of the songs he covers on Stars....
Yes, you read that correctly: for his second outing, Priggen elected to record a covers album. Given that he spent his entire life recording his debut, it's understandable that he might have trouble coming up with an album of new material in just two or three years, but it's still odd, to say the least. Even if the songs he covers aren't very well known, it's a strange career move.
Then again, after listening to Stars After Stars..., you get the idea that maybe writing your own material is overrated, particularly when you're able to make other people's songs sound so much like your own, as Priggen does. In part, this is because the songs he covers -- tracks from acts like Hot Bodies, the Pontiac Brothers and The Jacobites -- are hardly chart-topping hits, so Priggen can apply his Stipe-like vocals and power pop sensibilities to them without immediate concern about unfavorable comparison to the originals. Thus, Jennifer Jackson's "When You Looked At Me" becomes Beatles-tinged country-rock, while Hot Bodies' "In The Inside" and the Pontiac Brothers' "Be Married Song" evolve into big, crunchy pop-rock.
Songs by better-known acts give more of a sense of how much Priggen makes each tune his own. His version of Alice Cooper's "I'm Eighteen", for example, is just as rocking, but his twangy vocals are a distinct change. Similarly, his version of "Questioningly" is a million miles away from what The Ramones did with the original -- it would work well on an early REM record. In Priggen's hands, The Zombies' "How We Were Before" becomes a hybrid of power pop and flamenco, and Big Star's "Nightime" evolves into a beautifully understated acoustic lament.
It's unlikely that Stars After Stars After Stars will bring Priggen much attention or acclaim, except from power pop aficionados who have a thing for covers. That said, it's definitely worth your time to investigate it; not only is it free, but the accompanying blog functions as the sort of old-school liner notes most artists can't be bothered to provide, offering background information and revealing the personal significance behind each song choice. Priggen deserves a bigger, more devoted fan base, and Stars After Stars After Stars can only help it grow.-- Matthew Pollesel
Note From Spike: The music is actually only available as pretty low-res Realplayer files for the most part, although I have been putting them up as mp3s one at a time. I'm not actually giving it away for free (at least, I wasn't meaning to). Also, I've actually written many more songs than ended up on my first CD and have already recorded 11 songs for my next CD which will be all original songs. As far as it being a weird career move for me to record an all-covers record, I'd have to say, what career? Cool review though. Starts off like it's gonna be really negative, but I won him over!